NEW ORLEANS (AP) — A federal magistrate on Wednesday ordered BP to pay more than $130 million in fees to the court-supervised administrator of its multibillion-dollar settlement with Gulf Coast businesses and residents after the company’s 2010 oil spill.
The ruling comes as BP tries to temporarily block claims payments while former FBI Director Louis Freeh investigates allegations of misconduct by an attorney who worked on the settlement program. BP also has complained of broader problems in the program run by court-appointed claims administrator Patrick Juneau.
U.S. Magistrate Sally Shushan ruled that BP is obligated to fund the settlement program’s third-quarter budget even though she concluded the company raised “legitimate concerns” about Juneau’s operations.
In a letter Monday, BP claims official Maria Travis claimed Juneau’s office hasn’t provided adequate documentation for the money it requested. Travis also alleged that the program has been plagued by poor productivity and excessive costs.
Shushan said that while the dispute over claims documentation was regrettable, that there was no way she could cut off funding for administration of the program on such short notice.
“People are dependent. Jobs are dependent. We just can’t have that happen,” she said.
Shushan also ordered BP to pay for the first month of Juneau’s fourth-quarter expenses, giving the parties more time to resolve BP’s complaints about his budgeting process.
She ruled that Juneau must start submitting budget proposals 60 days before the start of a quarter, beginning with his budget for the first quarter of 2014.
Shushan gave both sides until 3 p.m. (1900 GMT) to appeal her ruling to U.S. District Judge Carl Barbier, who is overseeing the oil spill settlement.
BP attorney Keith Moskowitz said it is “patently unreasonable” to expect BP to pay more than $130 million without a more detailed budget proposal from Juneau. He said the one Juneau submitted in June was “in summary form without any backup.”
“That’s simply not how budgets are created. That’s now how businesses are operated,” he told Shushan.
Moskowitz said BP is not trying to shut down the program, but Juneau said the program would be in jeopardy if BP did not cover its expenses. “We’ve got bills that are due today,” he said.
Juneau also defended his operation and claimed BP’s characterization of his budget request was distorted.
“We give them what they ask for,” he said. “We give it to them in a format they ask for.”
In a separate request, BP has asked a second time for Barbier to suspend settlement payments until Freeh’s investigation is completed. The federal judge has not yet ruled on that request. Barbier appointed Freeh, now a private consultant, to investigate.
Lionel H. Sutton III, who resigned from Juneau’s office on June 21, has been accused of receiving a portion of settlement proceeds for claims he referred to a law firm before he went to work for Juneau.
In a court filing Monday, BP said there was evidence of additional fraud: The company said at least two lawyers who have ruled on appeals of disputed settlement awards were partners at law firms that have represented claimants and filed claims of their own for the firms to be compensated. BP also said it recently learned of allegations that someone employed by the settlement program at its Mobile, Alabama, center helped people submit fraudulent claims in exchange for a portion of the awards. Juneau’s office suspended that employee and a co-worker who allegedly helped that employee access claims data.
Based on the fresh allegations, BP renewed its request to delay claims, which Barbier had previously rejected.